Painting vs. Powder Coating

General Manufacturing, Industrial Coatings

Painting vs. Powder Coating: Which is Right for You?

When it comes to finishing metal surfaces, there are two main options: painting and powder coating. Each process has its own advantages and disadvantages. Whether you’re trying to decide on a finish for your outsourced parts, or maybe even looking to add a finishing application to your facility, it’s important to choose the right process for your parts.

Painting

Painting is the more traditional method of finishing metal. It involves applying a liquid paint to the surface, which then dries to form a protective layer.

The advantages of painting include:

It is relatively inexpensive.
It is easy to do yourself.
Easily touched up or repaired.
There are many different colors and finishes available.

The disadvantages of painting include:

Paint can be difficult to apply evenly, especially on complex shapes.
Paint can chip and peel over time, especially if it is not properly applied or maintained.
Paint can contain harmful solvents and VOCs.

Equipment needed for painting:

Paint booth (if painting indoors)
Paint mixing room (if mixing specific paints)
Paint sprayer/pump plus gun(s) and hose(s)
PPE

Powder Coating

Powder coating is a somewhat newer method of finishing metal that is becoming increasingly popular. It involves applying a powdered coating to the surface, which is then cured using heat.

The advantages of powder coating include:

It is more durable than paint and resistant to chipping, scratching, and fading.
Excess powder can be reused, creating less waste.
It can be applied to a wider variety of metal surfaces.
It is environmentally friendly, as it does not contain harmful solvents or VOCs.

The disadvantages of powder coating include:

It is more expensive than painting.
It cannot be applied to complex shapes without special equipment.
It requires more equipment and facility space.

Equipment needed for powder coating:

Powder coating booth
Curing oven
Racks, hooks, or other fixtures
Powder gun(s)
PPE

Which is Right for You?

The best way to decide which finishing method is right for you is to consider your specific needs and budget. If you are looking for a low-cost option, with a variety of colors and finishes, painting may be a good choice. Painting is also an ideal application for large items and mobile coating jobs. However, if you need a more durable finish that is resistant to damage, powder coating is the better option. Powder coating is an ideal application for small and medium sized parts.

Below is a summary of the main differences between painting and powder coating:

Characteristic	Painting	Powder Coating
Cost of Utilities	Less Expensive	More Expensive
Equipment Costs	Less Expensive	More Expensive
Cost of Materials	More Expensive	Less Expensive
Durability	Less Durable	More Durable
Ease of Application	Easier To Apply	More Difficult to Apply
Color & Finish Availability	Wide Variety Available	Limited Variety Available
Waste	More Waste	Less Waste
Environmental Impact	More Harmful Components	Less Harmful Components

Other items to consider when choosing are:

The type of metal being finished. Some metals, such as aluminum, are more difficult to paint than others.
The environment in which the finished product will be used. If the product will be exposed to harsh weather or chemicals, powder coating is a better choice.
The desired finish. Powder coating can produce a wider variety of finishes than painting.
The budget. Painting is generally the less expensive option, but powder coating may be worth the investment if you need a more durable finish.

In conclusion, both painting and powder coating have a place when it comes to finishing. Each have their strengths and weaknesses. Regardless of your choice, both can provide a fantastic finish on parts and equipment.

If you’re interested in finding out more information on equipment for painting or powder coating, contact our team today.

What You Need to Know About the 2022 Chemical Excise Tax

Foundry, General Manufacturing

What You Need to Know About the 2022 Chemical Excise Tax

And How It Affects the Manufacturing Industries

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has re-instated a previous chemical tax after a hiatus for over 25 years. This ‘new’ chemical tax has amendments including updated tax rates on chemicals and chemical substances. The taxable items are broken up as “taxable chemicals” and “taxable substances”.

When does the Chemical Excise Tax go into effect?

As of July 1^st, 2022 the Chemical Excise Tax is in full effect. The first return is due by October 31^st, 2022 for the calendar quarter that ends on September 30^th, 2022.

What is the tax rate?

The tax rate varies based on the type of chemical or substance. The rates range from as low as $0.44 per ton up to $9.74 per ton.

Which chemicals are included in the Chemical Excise Tax?

The IRS has compiled a list of “taxable chemicals” and “taxable chemical substances” that are to be taxed, which is subject to change. The “taxable substances” is considered as a substance that is comprised of more than 20% of one of the taxable chemicals, by weight or volume.

Scroll to the bottom for full list of chemicals and substances.

Who is responsible for paying the tax?

As stated by the IRS, “the manufacturer, producer, or importer of the taxable chemical is responsible for reporting and paying the section 4661 tax to the IRS. For taxable substances, the importer of the taxable substance is responsible for reporting and paying the section 4671 tax to the IRS.”

The taxes are to be reporting quarterly and payments be semimonthly. Those responsible for paying these chemical taxes must report them on IRS Form 720 and Form 6627.

How does this affect manufacturing industries?

Many chemicals in the excise tax are commonly used in many products throughout various industries, including foundry and parts cleaning applications. As this tax takes effect, price increases are likely from the manufacturers and importers of these products.

This tax affects such a wide range of chemicals that most industries will be affected. If you have any processes that use chemicals, you’ll be affected. Most of the affect as a use within your applications will come as prices increase long term from manufacturers and importers. Below are some specific items/processes that will be affected.

Foundry Industry

Some key items affected by this chemical tax will be sand binders, flux, adhesives, release agents, alloys, chromite sand, and more.

Parts Cleaning

Parts cleaning involves the use of various chemicals to aid in the cleaning of contaminants. Some of these chemicals may include the taxable items, driving a future increase in price on these items.

Have questions on how this affects you?

Contact our team and discuss potential proactive measures to prepare for this ‘new’ tax.

List of “taxable chemicals”:

Acetylene
Benzene
Butane
Butylene
Butadiene
Ethylene
Methane
Naphthalene
Propylene
Toluene
Xylene
Ammonia
Antimony
Antimony trioxide

Arsenic
Arsenic trioxide
Barium sulfide
Bromine
Cadmium
Chlorine
Chromium
Chromite
Potassium dichromate
Sodium dichromate
Cobalt
Cupric sulfate
Cupric oxide
Cuprous oxide

Hydrochloric acid
Hydrogen fluoride
Lead oxide
Mercury
Nickel
Phosphorus
Stannous chloride
Stannic chloride
Zinc chloride
Zinc sulfate
Potassium hydroxide
Sodium hydroxide
Sulfuric acid
Nitric acid

List of “taxable substances”:

1,4 butanediol
1,3-butylene glycol
1,5,9-cyclododecatriene
2-ethyl hexanol
2-ethylhexyl acrylate
2,2,4-trimethyl-1,3-pentanediol diisobutyrate
2,2,4-trimethyl-1,3-pentanediol monoisobutyrate
acetic acid
acetylene black
adipic acid
adiponitrile
allyl chloride
alpha-methylstyrene
aniline
benzaldehyde
benzoic acid
bisphenol-A
butanol
butyl acrylate
butyl benzyl phthalate
chlorinated polyethylene
cyclododecanol
decabromodiphenyl oxide
di-2 ethyl hexyl phthalate
di-n-hexyl adipate
diethanolamine
diglycidyl ether of bisphenol-A
diisopropanolamine
dimethyl terephthalate
dimethyl-2, 6-naphthalene dicarboxylate
diphenyl oxide
diphenylamine
epichlorohydrin
ethyl acetate
ethyl acrylate
ethyl chloride
ethylene dibromide
ethylenebistetrabromophthalimide
formic acid
glycerine
hexabromocyclododecane
hexamethylenediamine
isobutyl acetate
isopropyl acetate
linear alpha olefins
methyl acrylate
methyl chloroform
methyl isobutyl ketone
methyl methacrylate
monochlorobenzene
monoethanolamine
monoisopropanolamine

normal butyl acetate
normal propyl acetate
nylon 6/6
ortho-dichlorobenzene
ortho-nitrochlorobenzene
paraformaldehyde
para-dichlorobenzene
para-nitrochlorobenzene
para-nitrophenol
pentaerythritol
perchloroethylene
phenol
phosphorous pentasulfide
phosphorous trichloride
poly 1,4 butyleneterephthalate
poly (69/31 ethylene/cyclohexylenedimethylene terephthalate)
poly (96.5/3.5 ethylene/cyclohexylenedimethylene terephthalate)
poly (98.5/1.5 ethylene/cyclohexylenedimethylene terephthalate)
poly(ethyleneoxy)glycerol
poly(propylene)glycol
poly(propylene/ethylene)glycol
poly(propyleneoxy)glycerol
poly(propyleneoxy)sucrose
poly(propyleneoxy/ethyleneoxy)benzenediamine
poly(propyleneoxy/ethyleneoxy)diamine
poly(propyleneoxy/ethyleneoxy)glycerol
poly(propyleneoxy/ethyleneoxy)sucrose
polyalphaolefins
polybutene
polybutylene
polybutylene/ethylene
polycarbonate
polyethylene terephthalate pellets
propanol
sodium nitriolotriacetate monohydrate
synthetic linear fatty alcohols
synthetic linear fatty alcohol ethoxylates
terephthalic acid
tetrabromobisphenol-A
tetrachlorophthalic anhydride
tetrahydrofuran
texanol benzyl phthalate
toluene diisocyanate
toluenediamine
trichloroethylene
triethanolamine
triisopropanolamine
trimethylolpropane
vinyl acetate

Are Robotics Right For Your Application?

General Manufacturing

Are Robotics Right For Your Application?

A look at robotics and automation in the manufacturing industry

Automation and robotic use in manufacturing processes is a trend that continues to grow in use and popularity. Automated manufacturing leads to maximum efficiency and safety, offering a competitive advantage in the market. Robotic and automated operations accomplish repetitive tasks at a faster rate, eliminate the margins of human error, and allow for workers to focus their time and efforts on more important steps in the manufacturing process.

Basic Functions of Robotics

Robotics can be used in many different applications within a manufacturing facility including abrasive blasting, material handling, complex tasks, or product packing. The most common application of automated robots within manufacturing is for processes that require high-volume, speed, repetition and accuracy that a worker can’t provide.

Processing Features

Robots offer special processing options to ensure precision and quality in your manufacturing process.

Vision Camera System

3-D Parts Scanning System

Benefits of Robotic Manufacturing

Utilization of robots in the manufacturing process provides a number of benefits.

Improved Product Quality
Reduces EHS concerns
Quicker Production Rates
Lowers Worker Risk for Dangerous Tasks
Increased Production Output

Shorter Lead Times
Minimal Error = Reduced Waste & Increased Yield
Limited Down Time
Ability to Redeploy for Other Applications

The Rise of Cobots

Collaborative robots, or cobots, are quickly entering the manufacturing space. Cobots allow for tedious manual tasks to be done by a robot while working in the same space with humans without the risk factor of traditional robotics. This allows for a more collaborative environment as well as reduced floor space. Cobots eliminate the need for a caged off area for the robot to function and opens up extra space for humans to work around the cobot.

Let’s address some common objections to robotics.

Robots are expensive.

Yes. Robotics and automation are going to cost more upfront when you look solely at the equipment cost. Keep in mind, robotics are a long-term investment. They will continue to run for years, producing parts and making profit for your facility. The increased production will provide more opportunity for your business to do more jobs.

There are also indirect savings when robotics are implemented. Robotics reduce the margin of error which eliminates the need for extra labor, hours, waste and scrap created on a job.

Most robots will provide ROI in as little as two years.

Robots eliminate manufacturing jobs.

Robots aren’t solely used for worker replacement. Robots are versatile and are often implemented as an assisting source for workers who have intricate tasks. Robots will be utilized to lift, hold and move heavy pieces through a process while skilled workers execute intricate tasks.

While robots do replace the need for a worker to accomplish the repetitive tasks, they create a need for other positions such as programmers, engineers and maintenance to keep production rates at high levels.

How would robots fit within your process?

Robotic manufacturing is cost effective and can be designed for any size company. Engineers can look at your facility, production workflow and bottlenecks, to develop and implement the most cost-effective and productive automation processes.

Robots can be designed to work in confined spaces, accomplish tasks for multiple applications, strategically mounted to take up little floorspace, or be contained within a small finishing cell, allowing for safe walkways throughout your facility. Freeing up floor space to allow for future production and safe walkways throughout your facility.

Typical Applications:

Automated or Robotic Blasting Machines (Air or Wet Blasting)
Mass Finishing Systems
Deburring
Grinding, Buffing, and Polishing
Parts Cleaning Systems
Foundry Sand Molding Equipment
Material Handling

This leads us back to the question, are robotics right for you?

Automation and robotics can be implemented in large or small capacities to benefit any sized facility. Robotics and automation continue to be an integral part of manufacturing in facilities of all sizes, producing more manufactured parts at lower costs to compete with offshore companies. Our team of technically trained representatives can look at your facility, workflow, and processes to develop an efficient and the more cost-effective automation solution.

Video: An automated buffing system utilizing a robotic arm to move parts in and out of the finishing cell.

Find out how robotics and automation can improve your manufacturing facility

Talk to our team of technically trained representatives and schedule a site visit to see how automation and robotics can fit into your facility and increase your production rates.