The Importance of Chemistry in Vibratory Finishing

The Importance of Chemistry in Vibratory Finishing

The Importance of Chemistry in Vibratory Finishing

The Importance of Chemistry in Vibratory Finishing

How the Right Chemistry Can Transform Your Vibratory Finishing Process

Vibratory finishing equipment, or mass finishing, provides batch finishing processes for a multitude of parts such as descaling, deburring, polishing, cleaning, surface preparation, and other applications. These systems reduce labor and cut down on the total processing time spent on parts. There is a variety of vibratory equipment, media and chemistry utilized in the process. Each of these play a role in the final outcome of the part which is why it’s important to learn about each to ensure it’s the best fit for your process. This article will break down chemistry and how it affects the vibratory finishing process.

Types of Vibratory Chemistry

Vibratory finishing chemistry is engineered for specific applications to provide the best surface finish. These compounds ensure that your media and equipment continue to run at high production levels to meet your surface specifications. There are multiple types of chemistry for vibratory finishing processes:

  • Burnishing Compound – creates a highly polished and bright surface finish. Can also develop additional colors to the part.
  • Cleaning Compound – enhances the feed and roll of the mass as well as cleans the parts.
  • Deburring Compound – assists in removing burrs and provides smooth and refined surfaces while providing lubrication and reducing impingement.
  • Descaling Compound – removes tough oxide and carbonized oxide films.
  • Inhibiting Compound – protects parts from oxidation, corrosion, and tarnishing.

Why Vibratory Chemistry Is Important

Chemistry improves the vibratory finishing process through a variety of factors. It’s important to dial in each aspect of your process. Here are a few ways the chemistry will affect the process:

  • Cleaning and degreasing – The chemistry acts as a lubricant and surfactant, facilitating the breakdown and suspension of oils, greases, and other contaminants. This prevents them from redepositing on the parts and ensures thorough cleaning.
      • pH Control – Depending on the type of contaminants and workpiece material, the pH of the solution can be adjusted for optimal cleaning. Alkaline compounds are effective for greasy soils, while acidic solutions might be used for rust removal. Balanced pH also protects against corrosion.
  • Preventing media wear – the chemistry will keep the media clean and sharp, reducing the ‘glaze’ effect that can happen to tumbling media. The chemistry will also act as a lubricant, reducing friction between media and parts.
  • Process Control – Foam build up can hinder the finishing process by reducing the cutting action of the media. The chemistry can be formulated with anti-foaming agents to maintain appropriate foam levels.
  • Corrosion – Protecting parts from corrosion by utilizing rust inhibitors in the chemistry formula.

Improper use of chemistry or ratios can result in severe quality issues. If the chemistry is not suited for your process, or you don’t have the ratio correct, there can be inadequate contaminant removal, surface staining, corrosion, or pitting. There will also be a decreased life on your media, longer cycle times, and extra waste generated.

Best Practices for Utilizing Chemistry In Your Vibratory Finishing Process

Chemical Composition – There are many pre-mixed chemistries on the market. However, your process may need an engineered solution. It is recommended to run tests based on the part and the contaminants to create the most optimal solution for your cleaning process.

Concentration – Finding the best ratio for your finishing process in crucial. During testing, you will have an opportunity to develop the ratio of media, chemistry, and water. If your concentration is too low, there will be a drop in effectiveness and increase in cycle time. If the concentration is too high, there may be corrosion and damage done to the surface of the parts.

pH – The acidity or alkalinity of the solution can affect its cleaning power and compatibility with different materials. For example, acidic solutions might be ideal for removing rust but could damage delicate surfaces.

Temperature – Higher temperatures can increase the cleaning effectiveness by accelerating chemical reactions. However, certain materials can be damaged if the temperature is too high. It’s important to understand how the substrate will react with the chemicals.

Foam control – Excessive foaming can hinder the cleaning process by reducing contact between the solution and the surface. Anti-foaming agents are often used to control foam levels.

Rinsing Chemical Residue – Improper rinsing or residue build-up from the cleaning chemistry can affect subsequent finishing steps, like polishing or coating, requiring additional cleaning or rework.

Cycle Time – Controlling the amount of time the chemistry is in contact with the parts will affect the overall results of your finishing process. Some contaminants may require longer exposure times to be removed.

Other considerations for your vibratory finishing process are whether agitation or ultrasonics are needed, the type of surface you are cleaning, the contaminants, water quality, waste removal capabilities, and health hazards.

It is important to regular test and monitor your cleaning bath and waste. Not only will this ensure you are operating an effecting cleaning process, but will help create a safe work environment for your whole team.

The Right Chemistry Can Transform Your Vibratory Finishing Process

In the realm of vibratory finishing processes, the role of chemistry cannot be overstated. As discussed, the right chemistry is pivotal in achieving efficient, high-quality results across various applications, from deburring to polishing and beyond. Understanding the nuances of vibratory finishing chemistry empowers manufacturers to optimize their processes, enhance productivity, and uphold stringent quality standards.

vibratory finishing chemistry

Refine Your Mass Finishing Process

Testing your vibratory finish components is vital for refining your finishing process. Send us your parts and our processing lab will determine the right media and chemistry combination for your finishing application.

Painting vs. Powder Coating

Painting vs. Powder Coating

Painting vs Powder Coating

Painting vs. Powder Coating: Which is Right for You?

When it comes to finishing metal surfaces, there are two main options: painting and powder coating. Each process has its own advantages and disadvantages. Whether you’re trying to decide on a finish for your outsourced parts, or maybe even looking to add a finishing application to your facility, it’s important to choose the right process for your parts.

Painting

Painting is the more traditional method of finishing metal. It involves applying a liquid paint to the surface, which then dries to form a protective layer.

The advantages of painting include:

  • It is relatively inexpensive.
  • It is easy to do yourself.
  • Easily touched up or repaired.
  • There are many different colors and finishes available.
painting ppe

The disadvantages of painting include:

  • Paint can be difficult to apply evenly, especially on complex shapes.
  • Paint can chip and peel over time, especially if it is not properly applied or maintained.
  • Paint can contain harmful solvents and VOCs.

Equipment needed for painting:

  • Paint booth (if painting indoors)
  • Paint mixing room (if mixing specific paints)
  • Paint sprayer/pump plus gun(s) and hose(s)
  • PPE
graco paint sprayer
enclosed paint spray booth

Powder Coating

Powder coating is a somewhat newer method of finishing metal that is becoming increasingly popular. It involves applying a powdered coating to the surface, which is then cured using heat.

The advantages of powder coating include:

  • It is more durable than paint and resistant to chipping, scratching, and fading.
  • Excess powder can be reused, creating less waste.
  • It can be applied to a wider variety of metal surfaces.
  • It is environmentally friendly, as it does not contain harmful solvents or VOCs.
advantages of powder coating

The disadvantages of powder coating include:

  • It is more expensive than painting.
  • It cannot be applied to complex shapes without special equipment.
  • It requires more equipment and facility space.

Equipment needed for powder coating:

  • Powder coating booth
  • Curing oven
  • Racks, hooks, or other fixtures
  • Powder gun(s)
  • PPE
powder coating booth
powder coating oven

Which is Right for You?

The best way to decide which finishing method is right for you is to consider your specific needs and budget. If you are looking for a low-cost option, with a variety of colors and finishes, painting may be a good choice. Painting is also an ideal application for large items and mobile coating jobs. However, if you need a more durable finish that is resistant to damage, powder coating is the better option. Powder coating is an ideal application for small and medium sized parts.

Below is a summary of the main differences between painting and powder coating:

   Characteristic    Painting    Powder Coating
   Cost of Utilities    Less Expensive    More Expensive
   Equipment Costs    Less Expensive    More Expensive
   Cost of Materials    More Expensive    Less Expensive
   Durability    Less Durable    More Durable
   Ease of Application    Easier To Apply    More Difficult to Apply
   Color & Finish Availability    Wide Variety Available    Limited Variety Available
   Waste    More Waste    Less Waste
   Environmental Impact    More Harmful Components    Less Harmful Components

 

Other items to consider when choosing are:

  • The type of metal being finished. Some metals, such as aluminum, are more difficult to paint than others.
  • The environment in which the finished product will be used. If the product will be exposed to harsh weather or chemicals, powder coating is a better choice.
  • The desired finish. Powder coating can produce a wider variety of finishes than painting.
  • The budget. Painting is generally the less expensive option, but powder coating may be worth the investment if you need a more durable finish.

In conclusion, both painting and powder coating have a place when it comes to finishing. Each have their strengths and weaknesses. Regardless of your choice, both can provide a fantastic finish on parts and equipment.

If you’re interested in finding out more information on equipment for painting or powder coating, contact our team today.